QR-Code Email test

To:

alice@example.com, test@test.com

Cc:

test2@tst.com

Subject:

No Expansion of Mass Surveillance in Berkeley!

Dear Mayor and Berkeley City Council,
I am concerned about the proliferation of Mass Surveillance. Especially it’s installation and use right here in Berkeley. I am aware that the city and BPD are currently in the process of reviewing proposals from several surveillance companies, and i think there are multiple reasons that any mass surveillance as currently requested by the RFP, is bad news for Berkeley, for democracy and for our country.
1. The other vendors in the industry sell the same privacy invading and AI enabled technologies that Flock has. Also, some of them, Axon and Motorola specifically, directly contract the Department of Homeland Security. This seems like a conflict of interest if we are a Sanctuary City.
2. The ALPRS we currently have and that the city is requesting more of, track much more that our license plates. They identify and create profiles of every vehicle that passes, learning our travel patterns. The AI systems let officers search for people with descriptions, which puts all residents at risk of unwarranted searches, especially our most vulnerable populations.
3. If collected, the federal government has clear and legal pathways to accessing the surveillance data from the vendors without our knowledge. The City of Berkeley has acknowledged this risk. Under Trump, collecting data on people in Berkeley risks arming federal agents with targets for his war on immigrants.
4. Delegating investigative work to AI is problematic. If officers use AI to compile data from multiple sources and produce drafts of investigation reports, officers are no longer forming independent judgement about cases. They will have a harder time catching errors because they wouldn’t have reviewed the data in detail. Additionally, the AI systems make mistakes. With the 96% accuracy that Flock claims for license plate reads with its cameras, a 4% mistake rate on the 850,000 monthly scans in Berkeley means that 34,000 vehicles are misread every month. These misreads can swamp police with false leads: In Roseville, CA, 71% of stolen vehicle hits were misreads! These misreads can put innocent people at risk of dangerous law enforcement action for crimes they did not commit.
5. We need humans for crises response, not machines. Many 911 calls are for mental health crises or welfare checks. Replacing in-person assessments with a camera feed on drones, means high-stakes decisions will be made with incomplete information. The contract requires training for officers but sets no standards, which can create expensive legal liability when errors occur.
6. Public Safety requires addressing root causes. The strongest evidence-based approaches for improving public safety address the root causes, such as poverty, family instability, or cycles of violence exposure. Surveillance documents crime for law enforcement in the moment, but cannot address the conditions that lead to crime.
Mass surveillance has become an election-defining issue in Berkeley and across the country. We urge Council to respect the democratic will of Berkeley constituents and delay any decision on the RFP until after the newly elected council has been seated. The current schedule with a lame duck session of Council deciding the RFP disregards the will of Berkeley voters and will weaken trust with the City.
Please consider the grave danger that these technologies pose and help set out city on a path to democracy and join the hundreds of other municipalities who have recognized these dangers. Outlaw mass surveillance and pursue real people and community focused programs.
Respectfully,
Your Name

If the button doesn’t open the email in your preferred email program, copy the text here and paste it into whatever app you like. You can adjust the content and formatting in your email editor before sending.

Compose this email