Demand an accurate and independent audit

To:

council@berkeleyca.gov

Subject:

There must be an Independent Surveillance Technology Audit

Dear Mayor Ishii and Berkeley City Council,
I am a resident of [YOUR DISTRICT HERE], and I want to share some concerns about Mass Surveillance here in Berkeley.
Council will soon receive a Surveillance Technology report meant to reassure you that the technology here in Berkeley is used appropriately and strictly for the benefit of Berkeley residents. However, this audit of Flock ALPR’s conducted by the Berkeley Police Department is woefully inadequate. The City Council must demand an accurate, independent audit, and suspend all Flock ALPR usage until that report is conducted, reviewed and made publicly available.
I wanted to share just a few of the many reasons that the audit report is inadequate:
1. The audit does not test whether Flock complied with Berkeley’s data-retention and deletion requirements, yet the promise of city ownership and control of the collected data is a primary talking point for the pro-surveillance council members. How can we trust that these rules are being followed?
2. The audit does not meaningfully examine the enormous volume of third-party access. Over the 6 month period the audit covers, there were approximately 6,000 BPD queries, from which 100 were randomly selected and audited using Flocks own audit tools. Over this same 6 month period, there were approximately 960,000 third-party queries, yet the memorandum from BPD provides no comparable substantive sampling or validation of that vastly larger external universe. This is concerning because there is a known problem of ICE receiving information by proxy, either from other federal agencies or from police officers in jurisdictions that do not have strong sanctuary policies.
3. The audit’s keyword searches are not a meaningful assessment of whether or not there has been misuse. The findings assume that someone using the database for improper purposes is nonetheless going to follow the rules by accurately identifying the reason for their search. Reasons for searches can be easily concealed.
Again, please demand an accurate, independent audit, and suspend all Flock ALPR usage until that report is conducted, reviewed and made publicly available.
Respectfully,
[YOUR NAME]

If the button doesn’t open the email in your preferred email program, copy the text here and paste it into whatever app you like. You can adjust the content and formatting in your email editor before sending.

Send this email